Our ongoing projects extend Policy & Governace Lab’s (PGL) work on market-based, nonregulatory, and alternative forms of governance into new empirical territory, organized under two research initiatives. Several projects encompass multiple papers. Questions of managerial and organizational capacity, decentralized governance, political economy, and equity run throughout.
Focus: Systems-level, and multi-level policy, regulatory design, energy transitions, and emerging technology governance — with decentralized governance, equitable urban development, and environmental justice as central threads
1. Governance of AI Infrastructure and Data Center Supply and Demand
Status: Active data collection and data analysis | Team: Lily Hsueh (ASU), Ximing Dong (Ph.D. student, ASU)
The rapid expansion of hyperscale data centers has escalated over electricity demand, energy prices, water use, and local burdens on host communities. Cities, developers, and residents have responded with zoning rules, compensation, and collaborative agreements—often combined into rapidly evolving “package deals.” This project examines how these siting solutions have evolved and diffused, and what drives those shifts. Using a novel national dataset combining local siting documents, public engagement records, media coverage, and political and economic data, we trace a shift from isolated negotiations over zoning and permitting alone toward broader community benefit assurances, institutionalized collaboration, and emerging governance conflicts.
2. U.S. Tribal Energy Governance and Decarbonization Pathways
Status: Pilot study and data collection | Team: Lily Hsueh (ASU), Kimberly Yazzie (University of British Columbia), Chris Field (Stanford)
Tribal lands hold large potential for renewable energy, yet a quarter of Tribal households lack grid access, and regulatory complexity, underrepresentation in policymaking, and limited technical capacity slow development. Recent federal climate laws opened new paths to tax incentives and direct pay, though they have since been partly curtailed. This study examines how Tribal, state, federal, and private-sector actors interact to enable or impede clean energy development on Tribal lands. Through a mixed-methods comparative study drawing on public policy, economics, organizational behavior, landscape ecology, and Indigenous research methodologies, we aim to identify which institutional and fiscal tools best serve Tribal energy and economic priorities, keeping social and environmental justice at the forefront.
3. Renewable Energy Policy and Technological Innovation and Adoption: Evidence from OECD Countries
Status: Under review | Team: Eugene Cho (Ph.D. candidate, ASU), Lily Hsueh (ASU)
Which renewable energy policies best drive innovation and adoption? This first paper, now under review, compares feed-in tariffs (FIT) and renewable portfolio standards (RPS) across 30 OECD countries from 2000 to 2019, using patent registrations and renewable generation as measures. We find a significant synergistic effect: countries that combine both policies see more innovation than those using either alone. A five-country comparison (the United States, Canada, France, Germany, and the United Kingdom) further examines how relative energy prices shape renewable generation. The findings underscore the importance of policy design, and of ongoing evaluation, for both environmental goals and energy security.
4. Voluntary Carbon Markets and the Design of International Climate Clubs
Status: Working paper | Team: Lily Hsueh (ASU), Connor Nolan (Stanford)
A decade after the Paris Agreement, the voluntary carbon market faces a crisis of credit quality. Drawing on the “green clubs” framework, we analyze the market as a system of nested governance, from standard setters to certifiers to buyers, and show why oversight tends to weaken as the market scales, a dynamic we call “swords that dull.” Case studies of legacy and emerging programs show how quality uncertainty crowds out high-integrity projects. We propose a modular, multilevel design, with harmonized standards, independent enforcement, and buyer-pays models, to rebuild trust and align corporate incentives with real environmental gains.
Focus: Micro-level, firm-centered research opening the "black box" of the firm to examine how managerial agency, organizational capacity, and market forces shape corporate decarbonization strategies and firm–government interactions
5. Policy Signals, Managerial Agency, and Corporate Climate Action
Status: Working paper | Author: Lily Hsueh (ASU)
When do corporate climate commitments translate into substantive emissions reductions rather than remaining symbolic? Drawing on a multilevel political economy framework, this paper argues that corporate climate action depends on both bottom-up managerial agency and top-down regulatory signals. Using panel data on large U.S. publicly traded firms, it examines how managerial agency and organizational capabilities, reflected in dedicated leadership, environmental commitments, and innovation capacity, interact with external policy pressure, comparing firms that faced differing regulatory pressure in hard-to-abate and consumer-oriented sectors. Stronger policy signals increase participation in climate disclosure programs across sectors but reduce emissions intensity only when firms possess managerial capabilities. Managerial agency, in other words, does not operate in a vacuum; external policy signals activate and reinforce it.
6. Managerial Agency, Firm Dynamics, and Private-Public Interactions in Decarbonization Strategies
Status: Data analysis | Team: Mallory Flowers (University of Rhode Island), Lily Hsueh (ASU)
Are corporate climate responses driving physical decarbonization or accounting-based success? Some firms cut emissions through operational change, while others use reporting flexibility, such as the market-based method for Scope 2 emissions, to close gaps without changing energy use. Building on the framework in Corporations at Climate Crossroads, this project asks whether managerial capacity, including leadership commitment, technical expertise, and organizational culture, steers firms toward real energy transitions. Using a new panel of more than 500 publicly traded firms, we examine the gap between location-based and market-based emissions. The findings will inform how disclosure standards can reward genuine reductions.
For questions about these projects or request a paper, contact Dr. Hsueh at Lily.Hsueh@asu.edu.
For a deeper look into PGL's framework, you can watch Dr. Lily Hsueh's Book Talk on Corporations at Climate Crossroads, where she discusses how internal managerial and organizational dynamics and external regulatory pressures and global norms interact to shape corporate climate action.